While Gachagua publicly claims the DCP will organize impartial and transparent nominations, his simultaneous practice of selecting and backing favored candidates has revealed divisions within his party and sparked concerns about democratic processes.
His backed candidates include Mohamed Ali for Mombasa governor, Mithika Linturi for Meru governor, Kamau Murango in Kirinyaga, and Irungu wa Mai in Murang’a though the latter support is reportedly contingent upon incumbent Governor Irungu Kang’ata not joining DCP. Nelson Havi has also received his endorsement for Westlands MP.
These endorsements have nevertheless created discomfort among party members, with certain aspirants accusing leadership of predetermined results despite assurances of open primary elections.
The resulting tensions have already caused departures, most prominently Juja MP George Koimburi, who alleged the party had deceived hopeful candidates.
‘We were deceived,’ Koimburi stated when leaving, highlighting increasing discontent among local politicians who worry about being excluded from competition before nomination processes begin.
However, it is Gachagua’s extension of this endorsement strategy beyond DCP into the broader opposition coalition that is now triggering concerns.
During his recent political visit to Ukambani, Gachagua openly supported various leaders seeking re-election, such as Makueni Senator Dan Maanzo.
He also lent his support to Machakos Governor Wavinya Ndeti for the same position, an action that provoked opposition within the county.
Mavoko MP Patrick Makau, who also seeks the Machakos governor position, strongly criticized the endorsement, indicating emerging divisions that could intensify if such announcements continue.
He conveyed his disappointment that Gachagua had traveled to Mavoko to denigrate him before his party leader, Kalonzo Musyoka.
‘I perceived his words as disrespectful to Kalonzo. One cannot enter someone’s home and begin criticizing their child,’ Makau stated.
‘Therefore, his decision to lecture me before my party leader demonstrates his lack of respect for both the party and its leader.’
He noted it was regrettable that Gachagua was actively campaigning against him despite having voted for his impeachment.
‘I understand who dispatched him. We will be competing against them in the upcoming gubernatorial elections,’ Makau added.
‘Even those accompanying Gachagua, I question what they perceive in him. If my election to any position depends on Gachagua, I would rather not win.’
Although these endorsements may assist Gachagua in strengthening his influence and rewarding followers, applying this same approach to a multi-party opposition alliance risks isolating important allies and intensifying internal conflicts.
The United Opposition combines varied political figures with conflicting interests, regional support networks, and personal ambitions.
Premature endorsements, particularly from one principal, could therefore be viewed as an effort to control the coalition and determine its political course.
Prof Macharia Munene identifies this as the source of potential danger.
‘Strategies effective within a party framework may not function well in a coalition context. In a collaborative setting, endorsements can readily be perceived as forced directives,’ he explained.
‘He may be enjoying the public attention, but I haven’t witnessed the reciprocal situation where other principals are supporting candidates in his territory.’
The circumstances become more complex due to the opposition’s failure to formally establish a coalition framework, including procedures for nominations and power distribution.
His previous statement claiming an agreement with Kalonzo for DCP to present candidates in all positions created unease in the camp, with the Wiper leader publicly refuting such an arrangement.
Within DCP, the inconsistency between promising open primaries and granting direct endorsements continues to create uncertainty among hopeful candidates.
Nevertheless, DCP planning secretary Peter Mbae has insisted that the party will ensure the most qualified candidate receives the nomination.
‘Selection will not depend on who is more educated, who mobilizes effectively, or who brings more supporters,’ he stated on Wednesday.
‘We have informed the public that they will determine which MCA, MP, or Woman Representative they desire through primaries, and we will endorse that individual.’
When questioned about financial influence as alleged, Mbae stated that it would be imprudent for any party to accept funds from a candidate in exchange for a nomination, as they would subsequently lose that position.
‘The electorate will choose someone else who enjoys local popularity,’ he concluded.